When Farmland Stops Being Just Farmland Are Environmental Contracts Creating a New Rural Asset Class?
Long-term environmental agreements can create new income from farmland while also binding its management for decades. The bigger question may be what that does to the value, flexibility and future character of the asset.
For generations, agricultural land has been relatively straightforward to understand as an asset.
It produces crops.
It carries livestock.
It generates agricultural rent.
It appreciates, or occasionally depreciates, according to location, quality, demand and the wider land market.
Increasingly, however, some farmland is acquiring another characteristic.
Contracted environmental income.
Biodiversity Net Gain (BNG), conservation covenants and other long-term environmental agreements create the possibility of deriving income from environmental delivery rather than agricultural production alone. In doing so, they can also place obligations over land extending for decades.
Under England's statutory BNG framework, most qualifying development must deliver at least a 10% biodiversity gain, and off-site habitat improvements used within that framework can require legal agreements securing management for at least 30 years.
That immediately raises a business question considerably bigger than biodiversity.
If land has a contracted income stream, legally binding management obligations and a materially different range of future choices, should we still think about it simply as agricultural land?
Thirty Years Changes the Conversation
Thirty years is a remarkably long period in any business.
Over that time farms will change hands.
Partnerships will evolve.
Succession will occur.
Businesses will borrow money.
Families will restructure assets.
Markets will change.
Governments will change.
Technology will certainly change.
And yet an environmental agreement entered into today can remain relevant throughout much of that period.
Conservation covenants, for example, can impose positive or restrictive obligations relating to land and are designed to be capable of binding future owners rather than disappearing simply because the property is sold.
That means a landowner considering an environmental agreement is not merely deciding:
Is this income attractive today?
The business may also be deciding something about the characteristics of an asset for whoever owns it tomorrow.
That feels much closer to an investment decision than a conventional annual land-management choice.
Income and Restriction Can Exist Together
This is where environmental markets become particularly interesting.
A long-term environmental agreement may create a dependable contracted income stream.
That potentially strengthens cashflow.
But the same agreement may also constrain certain future uses of the land.
Those two things are not contradictory.
They are two characteristics of the same asset.
An office building let to a tenant produces rent while simultaneously restricting the owner's ability to do something else with the building during the lease.
The interesting proposition raised by Rupert Geering, a Chartered Surveyor and RICS Registered Valuer, is whether certain environmental land arrangements increasingly warrant similar investment thinking rather than being viewed solely through conventional farmland comparisons.
The Source article argues that familiar commercial valuation approaches, including consideration of the contracted income during the agreement and the value of the asset afterwards, may offer a useful framework for examining some long-duration environmental interests.
That does not mean farmland has suddenly become commercial property.
It means the financial characteristics of the asset may have become more complicated.
What Is The Land Actually Worth?
Consider the fundamental question faced whenever land is:
- sold;
- used as security for borrowing;
- transferred between generations;
- included within a wider business restructure.
What is it worth?
If conventional farmland has relatively little contracted annual income but another parcel carries a long-duration environmental payment, ignoring that difference altogether seems increasingly difficult to justify.
Equally, simply adding together thirty years of payments and calling the result additional land value would plainly be too crude.
Future income has risk.
The organisation making the payment matters.
Management obligations matter.
Compliance costs matter.
Inflation matters.
Liquidity matters.
And the land still has a value at the end of the contractual term.
This is where professional valuation judgement becomes important.
A Useful Illustration, Not A Market Valuation
Rupert Geering's original analysis includes a deliberately hypothetical example.
It considers 50 acres of grassland assumed to be worth £500,000 with vacant possession, generating £50,000 per annum under a hypothetical 30-year environmental lease.
Using assumed yields and discount rates solely to demonstrate the valuation method, the worked example produces an indicative value of approximately £825,000. Using a materially different rate for the eventual reversion reduces the calculated result substantially.
That difference is actually more interesting than either figure.
It demonstrates how sensitive long-term asset valuation can become to one deceptively simple question:
What do we believe the land will be worth, and capable of doing, when the agreement ends?
The £825,000 figure is not evidence that environmental agreements increase comparable farmland values by a particular percentage.
The Source explicitly describes its figures, rents and yields as hypothetical assumptions rather than market evidence.
The value of the example is therefore conceptual.
It shows why the contract cannot necessarily be separated from the asset when thinking about value.
What Happens in Year 31?
This may be the most difficult question of all.
Government guidance provides an important clarification.
When a 30-year BNG agreement ends, a landowner is not necessarily committed to maintaining that land within BNG forever. Future options may include continuing biodiversity management, participating in other nature markets or choosing other uses where legally and practically possible. Government guidance also notes that reversing habitat works may carry implications.
So RBI would be wary of making either of two assumptions.
The first is:
The land simply becomes conventional farmland again after thirty years.
The second is:
Once entered into environmental use, the land can never practically become anything else.
Neither should be treated as inevitable today.
The more useful question is:
What might the economically and environmentally rational use of this land be in thirty years?
Nobody can answer that with certainty.
But anybody signing a long-term agreement should probably be asking it.
Lending Changes the Discussion Again
Land value matters because land does more than produce income.
It is also part of the capital structure of many rural businesses.
Farm property frequently supports borrowing, future investment and succession planning.
Once land is subject to long-term environmental obligations and associated income, lenders and professional advisers may therefore need to understand considerably more than acreage, agricultural productivity and local comparable sales.
What is the environmental agreement?
Who is the counterparty?
How secure is the income?
What obligations remain with the landowner?
What happens if another party fails?
What would a purchaser inherit?
How easily could the asset subsequently be sold?
These are not reasons to avoid nature markets.
They are reasons to treat them as serious business arrangements.
Tax Cannot Be Considered Afterwards
Tax treatment adds another layer.
HMRC confirms that Agricultural Property Relief has been extended to qualifying agricultural land managed under certain environmental agreements, with the extension applying from 6 April 2025.
Meanwhile, inheritance-tax valuation remains centred on the statutory concept of the price property might reasonably fetch if sold on the open market at the relevant time.
For RBI readers, the practical lesson is not to attempt the tax calculation themselves.
It is almost the opposite.
The tax, valuation, contractual and succession consequences belong in the conversation before a long-term environmental commitment is signed, not afterwards.
A thirty-year decision warrants joined-up advice.
Valuation Practice Is Having To Evolve Too
This is not solely a landowner problem.
The professional framework surrounding rural assets is also adapting.
RICS' current Red Book Global Standards, effective from 31 January 2025, include changes reflecting evolving environmental, social and governance considerations alongside developments in valuation methods and modelling.
RICS has also addressed BNG and conservation covenants in relation to property and land valuation.
That matters because environmental markets remain relatively young.
Traditional farmland enjoys decades of comparable transactions.
Long-duration environmental contracts do not yet provide the same depth of evidence.
Professional judgement therefore becomes more, rather than less, important.
Is This A New Asset Class?
Perhaps.
But RBI would be cautious about declaring that environmental land has already become a distinct asset class.
Rupert Geering's argument is that contracted environmental land increasingly exhibits characteristics more usually associated with long-income investment assets.
There is certainly something changing.
Land can now potentially combine:
an underlying freehold asset
with
contracted environmental income
and
long-duration management obligations.
Those characteristics deserve recognition.
Whether the market ultimately decides they represent a distinct rural asset class will become clearer as more agreements are signed, more transactions occur and better valuation evidence develops.
For now, perhaps the more useful conclusion is simply this:
some farmland is becoming financially more complicated than the word "farmland" suggests.
The RBI Reflection
Natural-capital markets are often discussed in terms of opportunity.
How much biodiversity income could this field generate?
What might carbon be worth?
Could environmental delivery create another revenue stream?
Those are perfectly reasonable questions.
But they are only half the conversation.
The other half concerns the asset itself.
What happens to:
- future use;
- borrowing;
- sale;
- succession;
- management obligations;
- tax;
- long-term optionality?
The attraction of contracted income is understandable.
So is the attraction of environmental improvement.
Neither removes the need to understand what a thirty-year commitment means for the business behind it.
Perhaps the biggest change created by nature markets is therefore not that farmland can earn money in another way.
It is that some land may increasingly need to be considered simultaneously as:
productive land, environmental infrastructure and a long-duration investment asset.
And once that happens, the question is no longer simply:
How much can this land earn?
It becomes:
What are we turning this asset into?
That feels like the more important question.
Acknowledgement
This article was prompted by analysis from Rupert Geering MSc MRICS PSAg of Geering Chartered Surveyors, examining the valuation implications of long-term environmental agreements affecting agricultural land. RBI independently reviewed the underlying BNG, conservation covenant, taxation and professional valuation framework before developing the wider business discussion.
References – Oxford Style
Geering, R., ‘Valuing Nature Contracts: Why Agricultural Land Appraisal Needs a Rethink’, Geering Chartered Surveyors / Society of Agriculture, 14 October 2026.
Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, Biodiversity Net Gain: Legal Agreements, GOV.UK, accessed October 2026. [gov.uk]
Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, Biodiversity Net Gain Guidance, GOV.UK, accessed October 2026. [gov.uk], [gov.uk]
Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, guidance on land management following the 30-year Biodiversity Net Gain period, GOV.UK, accessed October 2026. [defraenvir...log.gov.uk]
HM Revenue & Customs, guidance on Agricultural Property Relief and land managed under environmental agreements, GOV.UK, accessed October 2026. [gov.uk], [gov.uk]
HM Revenue & Customs, inheritance-tax valuation guidance and the open-market value principle under section 160, Inheritance Tax Act 1984, accessed October 2026. [legislation.gov.uk], [gov.uk]
Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, RICS Valuation – Global Standards (Red Book), effective 31 January 2025. [rics.org], [rics.org]
Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, guidance and commentary concerning Biodiversity Net Gain and conservation covenants in land and property valuation, accessed October 2026. [ww3.rics.org], [ww3.rics.org]