The New Farm Spending Rule: Prove It Works
When margins tighten and uncertainty grows, the strongest challengers do not stop innovating. They simply raise the bar. This article examines how farmers are becoming more selective about where they invest, what they expect from technology, and why proving value may be more important than ever.
Why the most resilient businesses are not abandoning innovation but becoming far more selective about it.
The agricultural industry has never lacked challengers.
Every generation has produced new ideas, technologies and business models promising to reshape farming. Some have transformed the industry. Others have disappeared as quickly as they arrived. What separates the two is rarely marketing, ambition or novelty. In challenging times, the deciding factor is often much simpler: does it work?
Recent findings from the Global Farmer Insights 2026 report by McKinsey & Company suggest that farmers across the world are entering a new phase of technology adoption. The report, based on responses from 5,500 farmers across ten countries, found businesses becoming more cautious with spending as profitability comes under pressure and uncertainty remains high. Yet despite this caution, innovation has not stopped. Far from it.
Instead, farmers appear to be becoming far more selective about where they place their bets.
That distinction matters.
For much of the past decade, discussion around agricultural technology has focused on possibility. Could artificial intelligence transform decision-making? Could biological products reduce dependency on conventional chemistry? Could data, automation and precision technologies deliver better outcomes?
Today the conversation is changing.
The question is no longer what technology might achieve. It is what technology can demonstrate.
That shift perfectly reflects the spirit of challengers.
The most successful challengers are not necessarily those developing the newest products. They are the businesses capable of solving real problems for real customers. When margins tighten and risk increases, farmers become less interested in promises and more interested in evidence.
According to McKinsey, farmers are preserving cash and delaying expenditure where possible. Spending intentions have declined significantly since the previous survey, reflecting a period of economic caution across global agriculture. Yet at the same time, respondents continue to invest in technologies capable of delivering clear value.
This should not be viewed as resistance to change.
If anything, it reflects a more sophisticated approach to innovation.
For businesses supplying products and services to agriculture, this creates both a challenge and an opportunity. The challenge is obvious. Selling on aspiration alone is becoming increasingly difficult. Product claims, however impressive, are subject to greater scrutiny than ever before.
The opportunity lies in validation.
Businesses that can demonstrate measurable improvements in productivity, efficiency, resilience or profitability may find farmers more receptive than expected. In difficult conditions, proven solutions become even more valuable.
One of the most interesting findings from the report concerns biological products. McKinsey identified biologicals as a relative bright spot within agricultural innovation, with adoption continuing to grow despite broader spending pressures.
Again, the lesson is not simply that biologicals are gaining momentum.
The deeper lesson is that farmers appear willing to invest when they believe a technology addresses a genuine challenge. Whether that challenge is input costs, soil health, sustainability targets, resistance management or productivity, adoption is being driven by practical outcomes rather than fashionable trends.
The same principle applies to artificial intelligence.
McKinsey found growing use of generative AI among farmers, particularly in planning and crop management activities. At first glance, that may seem remarkable for an industry often characterised as cautious or traditional. However, another finding is arguably even more significant. Farmers continue to place far greater trust in advisers, agronomists and established relationships than in AI-generated recommendations alone.
For RBI readers, this should sound familiar.
The rural economy has always been built on trust.
Technology may accelerate decision-making. Data may inform decisions. Artificial intelligence may help identify options. But ultimately, decisions still depend upon credibility, experience and confidence. The importance of trusted advisers remains remarkably resilient even as digital adoption increases.
This presents an important challenge for technology providers.
Winning in agriculture is not merely about developing better software, smarter algorithms or more advanced platforms. It is about building trust. It means translating technology into practical outcomes that fit the realities of individual businesses, landscapes and enterprises.
In many respects, this is where challengers thrive.
Established businesses often rely on legacy relationships or market position. Challengers succeed when they identify a problem that others have overlooked and deliver a solution that customers can clearly measure.
That lesson extends far beyond agriculture.
Across the rural economy, businesses face the same pressures: rising costs, uncertain markets, labour challenges and increasing demands on capital. Whether operating in food production, engineering, retail, tourism or professional services, leaders are being forced to ask harder questions about investment decisions.
What will improve performance?
What will reduce risk?
What will create value?
And perhaps most importantly:
Can it be proven?
For years, innovation has often been associated with speed. The latest technology. The newest product. The next breakthrough.
The findings from McKinsey suggest something different.
The next generation of winners may not be the businesses moving fastest. They may be the businesses demonstrating value most effectively.
That is a powerful message for challengers.
In an environment where confidence is fragile and capital is precious, farmers are not rejecting innovation. They are raising the standard required to earn their investment. Products, technologies and services that can withstand that scrutiny may emerge stronger than ever.
The challenge for innovators is no longer simply to be different.
The challenge is to prove it works.
Sources: Based on findings reported in Global Farmer Insights 2026 by McKinsey & Company and analysis by Agri-TechE.